The more we pretend to read…

mark as read

I went on Facebook, saw I had a number of notifications, clicked to glance at the list, and then clicked “Mark as read.” Don’t ask me what was in the list. Don’t ask me any details. Certainly don’t give me any test over the material. But I did “read” them — about as intentionally as my students just read Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice.

Students don’t read like they once did.

I know I sound prejudiced, but I prefer to think  my statement a byproduct of empirical evidence, and I’m not proud of my observations. I am saddened. I have been teaching English for nearly 15 years, the bulk of that time dedicated to honors and Advanced Placement English students in 11th and 12th grades. You would think these high-caliber students would read not just what I assign but more, so much more.

Certainly, they’ve heard the saying, “Readers are leaders.”

I am frightened to think that those who don’t read may someday lead.

My thoughts are trending on reading today for three, perhaps four, reasons.

Friday I gave a final test over Pride and Prejudice. We have been studying the book for a month; I even gave students the questions to answer from which I would build the plot questions on the test. I warned students that the test would also cover the author, the theme, the characters, and the literary devices Austen uses in her classic text. I said they could read the zombie version if that would make them more likely to read. I said they could watch the six-hour movie version if that would aid their reading.

But I said they had to read. And take notes in class. If they did both — and some, to be fair, surely did — they would pass with high marks. Based on my advice to students, our class discussions, and the notes I jotted myself on the white board — and recorded with my camera phone — I wrote a fair test. Some still found it quite difficult. Some left questions unanswered. Some whined — but could not admit they’d really read.

Yesterday, I read a woman’s blog titled, “How school put a stop to my child’s habit of reading.”  In it, the author reveals how she cultivated a love of reading in her child through the years. However, once in high school, the author’s daughter took a standardized test that would determine the level of classes she would take; she was placed in “mixed ability” classes, where, apparently, her new peers do not read (as indicated when the teacher quizzed them).  To encourage reading, the teacher asked students to bring in a “suitable” book and gave them time to read each day in class. As the blogger wrote, it sounded logical, but the result has been that her child now only reads in that brief interval at school.

I was so touched by her post that I had to issue my comment:

Great post — and sad!  You are right, the school likely thinks it is doing a good thing by insisting on this and “inspiring” reading, and your daughter is likely caving to peer pressure. I am an English teacher who struggles to get students engaged in reading; some do, most don’t enjoy reading for pleasure. In many ways, I blame social media, tweeting, texting, and other shallow “sports” that purport to use real communication. My son, for instance, loves Vines, 6-second videos usually of no value that replay and replay and replay. I have taught English for 15 years, and the students are coming into my class less able to read than before. They don’t understand the context or the vocabulary and, I think, actually lack the ability to comprehend and, therefore, dislike reading more than ever. 

 A friend shared this video with me that I thought you might enjoy… it is a funny diatribe on our American inability to read the classics…

That video link I shared with the blogger is my third reason for trending on reading. The video is a comedian’s rendition of The Three Little Pigs, if the book had been written (and performed) by William Shakespeare; the lone American pig (with his limited vocabulary) adds hilarity and an unfortunate truth on our lost culture of reading.

Within the two years juniors and seniors are in my English classroom, I try to emphasize the importance of reading and of books.  When students read To Kill a Mockingbird, for instance, they go into the grammar classroom with main character Scout and find a teacher who discourages her habit of reading with her father, which leads the little girl to this thought:

“Until I feared I would lose it, I never loved to read. One does not love breathing.”

Next quarter, my students will tackle Frederick Douglass’s autobiography; he was an American slave who learned to read and attributed his rise to freedom to that very act. One of my favorite books to teach, Fahrenheit 451, by Ray Bradbury, is all about a society so bombarded by technology and mass communication that the people are forbidden to read. Taking away books allowed egality — a drastic leveling of society so that no one need feel inferior. In Bradbury’s society, firemen exist to burn — books — rather than to put out fires. While he wrote in response to the literal book burnings he saw in Nazi Germany, the now-deceased Bradbury said this:

“You don’t have to burn books to destroy a culture. Just get people to stop reading them.”

I fear that day is fast approaching.

Do you realize how important reading is? How crucial understanding words are? How reading is the crux of the matter to those with faith in God?  Jesus Christ was the Word of God who became flesh and dwelt among us. The Bible is God’s word to us — but we have to read it. Once upon a time only the leaders in the faith had access to the word of God, and the rest of the people were dependent on them for both its reading and its understanding. One Reformation and the invention of the printing press later, and we all were free to have God’s word in our hands. But with the dumbing down of our society, the lowering of our vocabulary, the reduction of our time actually reading, the increase in our exposure to technology and mass communication, that freedom may be threatened not by government but by desire — or inability. And we probably won’t even realize it.

I see it in the children I teach.

Some of my students may not pass my test on Pride and Prejudice, but they likely will pass my class and pass on into college life. And when asked if they have ever read Pride and Prejudice, they will likely say they have.

Like my Facebook notifications, my students will “mark as read” Pride and Prejudice. But the more we pretend to read, the more we will be missing the mark.


14 responses to “The more we pretend to read…”

  1. Brittany Avatar

    Well done


    1. sarahas5 Avatar

      Thank you. And thanks for really reading!


  2. Rose Red Avatar

    I completely agree with what you are saying here. The loss of reading ability, and the desire to read, is a tragedy. Like you, I feel that something is being lost. Technology and shortened attention spans have much to do with it, and maybe the fact that books are seen as uncool for kids? I have never read Fahrenheit 451 but I intend to now that I have read your post.

    I enjoyed reading this – and thank you for the feedback on my post!


    1. sarahas5 Avatar

      Thanks, Rose Red, for your comments — and for not minding my referring to your blog post within my own. I appreciate your inspiration and happy to find someone like-minded. Enjoy Fahrenheit!


      1. Rose Red Avatar

        I am sure I will 🙂


  3. Heather Avatar

    I love to read! I told my mom one day when we were in a bookstore, “no one reads books anymore” and I said it as a joke, but honestly, it’s so true and sad! Reading is so good as it allows new words to be built into ones vocabulary and helps to expand horizons of learning new things! I always love reading your work! You are so engaging!


    1. sarahas5 Avatar

      Thanks so much, Heather! I admit that I hardly go to bookstores anymore. I more often read books on my Kindle — but I am still reading! I am afraid that isn’t the case for too many. Thanks for loving to read — and sharing that love to read with my blog by reading! Keep it up!


  4. Shirley McCarty Avatar
    Shirley McCarty

    Thanks for articulating this so well. I couldn’t agree with you more. I actually read this out loud to my youngest, who is now a college freshman. Let’s see what can I get him to read while he is home on break? I really enjoy reading what you write, thanks for the time you take to share your talent!


    1. sarahas5 Avatar

      Thanks, Shirley! I guess I should read this aloud to my youngest, a senior in high school (and one of the pretend readers in my English class). It is hard to combat the ease of entertainment and even learning prevalent in our society. Reading, apparently, is work, but to those of us already in love with it, it is worth any effort it may take. But how to get others to buy in to this? That is the question! Keep me posted! (Thanks for reading!)


  5. Peggy Avatar

    Sadly, I have to agree. In our world of instant information and instant this and that…we have become accustomed to getting our gratification instantly. If we don’t get that in the first few pages of a book, we put it down.

    I wonder if it has less to do with schools, and more to do with our overall busyness in life that we neglect to read to our children while they are young. We read books out loud to our children as part of our homeschool and my husband reads to them as they go to sleep. And not twaddle…but books with character that teach things like honor, integrity, and more that we just don’t see anymore. A great source of such books is Lamplighter Publishing. They publisher rare old books that are rife with drama, intrigue and more! We even take the radio dramas and listen to them in the car.

    But alas, as your post reveals, we are probably a lost and dying breed. We ALL love to read. As a home educator, my goal is not to educate, but teach a love of reading! In my high school English class is the first place I remember hearing the phrase, “If you give a man a fish, he will eat for day. If you TEACH him to fish, he will eat for a lifetime.” That is my approach with my children. Give them skills so that they can learn for themselves and WANT to learn for themselves! I know it is yours, too.

    I can see your heart and your passion in your post! Your students are blessed to have such a fine teacher!


    1. sarahas5 Avatar

      Thanks so much, Peggy! Your comment is refreshing and true. I did homeschool my children for a number of years before we all went to school together. My youngest son is not an avid reader, despite loving books all through his youth. It is hard, as his mother and English teacher, to find the right way to romance his heart back to books…. the immediate nature of technology is so much more appealing.

      Congratulations on teaching your children at home! I loved those days with my children and will remember them always with great fondness.

      Thanks for commenting!


      1. Peggy Avatar

        LOVE that phase, “Romancing his heart back to books”. It really is true, isn’t it? We have to find books that we think they will like and introduce them in a casual way, in a way that will pique their interest. They hope it takes off! 😛


  6. I Read the Bible in One Year; This Is What It Did for Me – All things work together Avatar

    […] the context to understand those great works. (I wrote about it in a compelling post about “The More We Pretend to Read.“) Because I’ve never been a great student of history, I will have to work harder to […]


I’d love to hear from you! Leave a comment.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: